‘The Thing’ – Iconic Supernatural!


Two great episodes in a row, Season 13! We’re on a roll! I loved this week’s Supernatural episode for all the reasons that I love the Show itself. There is nothing more iconic Supernatural than one brother losing – and then saving — the other, and that’s exactly what happened in ‘The Thing’. There’s also nothing more iconic for this Show than the Winchesters being brothers, and we got that too – the balance between the humor and the emotional was exactly what I most love about this Show. Thank you, Davy Perez, for writing such an entertaining and satisfying episode.

The episode was chock full of protective Winchesters, which is my favorite flavor. Sometimes they were protecting a monster-god who was going to turn around and try to eat them, but that’s in keeping with the mistaken identity theme that Season 13 has had going from the start. (I’m still not 100% sure about Cas). This time it was Sandy Porter – well, the young woman who used to be Sandy Porter and is now the god Yokoth (Magda Apanowicz). I have to hand it to Yokoth, she played an alarmingly realistic version of woman-who’s-mysteriously-awakened-after-100-years. I suppose she was just biding her time until she figured out who to eat and who to breed with (Dean Winchester because of course it is) but she did a great job of it, looking all mystified and damsel-in-distressy. Sam and Dean, good guys that they are, totally fall for it.

After the opening scene in which Sandy is sacrificed to the tentacle monster by the creepy chanting robe-wearing people (shout out to the VFX wizards who made a tentacle monster genuinely SCARY), Sam and Dean are in the bunker trying to find that elusive last ingredient so they can open a rift of their own and get Mom and Jack back. Sam, ever the diligent researcher, has fallen asleep on the table. So Dean, ever the considerate big brother, proceeds to affix derogatory post it notes all over his back.

Ackles is so good at the subtle facial expressions as Dean tries hard not to wake Sam up, shaking his head no no no when Sam stirs and then resuming his little game when he falls back to sleep. When Sam does wake up, Dean not so casually pretends he was doing absolutely nothing – Sam is clearly suspicious, because he knows his brother, but can’t find anything amiss. It hearkened back to Season 1, when the brothers were constantly playful with each other, and I loved that little interlude.

The fact that Dean is playing this little game only for the benefit of the two of them somehow made it even more endearing. The reminder that no matter what else they’ve been through, Sam and Dean are still and always brothers, was so very welcomed.

The Winchesters check the MoL archives (which aren’t as gigantic and impressive as I expected, to be honest…) with Dean throwing up his hands and announcing sarcastically “I love books!”

He continues to tease Sam as they research, breaking up the monotony by acting like he found something only to say “Nothing” when Sam demands to know what he found.

Oh Dean.


Sam heads back to his room eventually and finds the post it notes all over his back, and yells for Dean.

Sam: Are you serious?

Dean: Oh yeah, hilarious – I found it!

Smart!Dean kept on researching despite his protests about hating it, and now they know where to look for the Seal. (Dean can’t pronounce capitulum but come to think of it, how many of us have ever said that word aloud?)  I don’t particularly like the bit that Show does where Dean can’t pronounce things, since we know he’s proficient with Latin and just plain smart, but in this case, I’ll let it slide. I did like his immediate “yeah” when Sam explains that it means chapter house, like he knew it all along. Also Dean may not be keen on sitting down and doing research all day, but he DOES read books – that’s canon. He’s proficient with Greek myths and nuanced readings of Vonnegut, after all.

Best part of that scene?

Dean’s triumphant “Jinkies!” and Sam’s bitch face in response.

Sam: You’re gonna stop saying that eventually, right?

Dean: I don’t know. Probably not.

I loved the call back to last week’s episode and the boys being so absolutely in character. Of COURSE Dean would still be saying Jinkies!

The Winchesters drive to Rhode Island and find the ‘hidden’ entrance, which requires them to swing down through a manhole cover and drop a dozen feet or so into the underground bunker – which means we get some A+ gifs of Jared and Jensen doing their own stunts. Like, really well.

Competent Winchesters kink, check. This episode checked off a lot of boxes.

The interior shots in this other Men of Letters bunker are gorgeous, the lighting just right to set off our boys coming down the hallways with their flashlights. It all looks pretty familiar, except that the seal on the doors is a bit different, so there’s a mystery here for sure.

Dean notices some old photos, including one of Sandy Porter, and Sam finds the book about the Seal – and then someone is screaming for help and the boys are taking off down the hall. It’s in their blood to save people, and maybe that’s why they don’t think about it too hard when Dean realizes the woman chained to the altar is none other than Sandy Porter, who should be over a hundred years old but doesn’t look a day over 25.

They take Sandy to a back roads diner that is also an iconic Supernatural thing — unfortunately most of the time very bad things happen at these iconic diners on this Show. This time is no different. Dean is sweet, putting on the juke box for Sandy, and the brothers banter about their divergent food tastes.

Sam: I’m watching my cholesterol, and you should be too.

Dean: I’m watching my cholesterol….go up.

Me: Boys.


Meanwhile, we see that chef Marco is alarmed by Sam and Dean and Sandy, causing him to drug Sam and Dean’s food. At this point he seems like bad guy, but his arm has that odd MoL symbol as a tattoo. Also he has a very big knife. Hmm.

An innocent young restaurant patron who should probably have been wearing a red shirt expresses concern when he sees a bunch of creepy looking people in hooded robes surrounding the diner.

Guy: Hey, something weird’s going on….

The internet: That could be the description of every Supernatural episode ever…

Sam offers to go back to the other bunker by himself to check something out that I can’t remember, but Dean stops him.

Dean: No, I’m not letting you go back there by yourself!

It’s the first time in the episode that Dean goes into protective big brother mode, but it won’t be the last. Iconic Winchesters, check.

Before the Winchesters can investigate further, Sam starts to feel woozy and then passes out, much to Dean’s alarm.

Dean: Sam, hey hey…

That’s what the Winchesters say to each other when one of them is hurt and the other is worried, and the continuity and the familiarity of it brings tears to my eyes every time.

A fight breaks out and holy crap do we ever get badass Dean Winchester! With Sam out of commission and vulnerable, Dean takes on the whole group of them, kicking and punching and even grabbing a tray from the kitchen to bash one of them. Stunt coordinator Rob Hayter once again did a fabulous job with the choreography, as did Jensen.

From the other room, Sam wakes up groggily and calls out for his brother.

Sam: Dean!

Dean: (in the middle of the fight) Sammy!

If anything is iconic Supernatural, that is it right there.

The mysterious robed people manage to put a hood over Sam and take him away. Dean is saved by Sandy stabbing the guy he’s fighting with, and immediately runs out into the front of the diner calling for his brother.

Dean: Sammy!

He wastes no time trying to get Sam back. In fact, he starts building bombs.

Dean: They took my brother. I’m gonna get him back.

Damn right he is.

Yep, iconic Supernatural, 100%. I’m a happy fangirl.

The people who took Sam turn out to be Men of Letters legacies too, except that their grandfather went a little off the rails and decided to try to make over the world to be less violent by summoning a god from another dimension to start over (as you do).  Which promptly ate him and anyone else nearby. Shockingly. So they shut the god up in the bunker and Marco  (Carl Montoya) and his sister Ophelia (Tiffany Smith) have been keeping her locked up there ever since.

Poor Sam and Dean inadvertently let her out. Oops.

Marco and Ophelia: All she wants to do is eat….and breed.

Me: Oh I can see where this is going…

Meanwhile, back at the diner, the clueless red shirt kid is heroic and goes outside to investigate – and promptly gets eaten by Sandy with her tentacle tongue. Ewww.

Dean rushes outside when he hears the guy’s scream, and Sandy turns her tentacle tongue on him. Fade to black.

Sam and company return to the diner only to find it’s too late, Sandy has definitely eaten.

Waitress to Sam: Stringbean! You’re not dead!

Sam: Not yet.  Where’s my brother??

Once again, iconic Supernatural. Don’t waste my time, I need to find my brother!

Marco and Ophelia: She got food in her belly….

They also get the unforgettable line “If she’s not feeding, she’s breeding….”

That explains why Dean’s body isn’t there with the other hapless patrons.

Cut to Dean chained to the altar.

Me: I think I read this fic…

Sandy complains to him that her mate was supposed to come through the rift with her but it closed before he could.

Dean: Oh my god that’s tragic…it’s like a Hallmark movie…with tentacles…

Only Dean Winchester is still a smartass chained to an altar by a god monster.

Sandy: I like you, Dean. You’re strong and I enjoy looking at your face.

Dean: You’re makin’ me blush…

Me: Gods on this show always have good taste.

Sandy/Yokoth informs Dean that because of those attractive attributes, he’ll be allowed to be the host for her mate – which Dean does not appreciate.

She does the spell and the rift opens, and down come the tentacles as Dean lays there bound and chained and honestly I’m pretty sure I’ve read this fic more than once and I have to wonder how much fanfiction Davy Perez has been enjoying. (Which is definitely not a criticism)

Dean is cagey enough to dodge the tentacle with the sucker on it because he’s Dean Winchester, but the rest of the tentacles wrap around him as he struggles to get free. Oh yes, definitely read this. Maybe more than once.

Then it’s Sam to the rescue, as he bursts in to save his brother. With Sandy distracted, Dean picks the lock and tosses the Seal to Ophelia. She recites the spell and Sandy’s mate is sucked back up through the rift, grabbing her at the last minute and taking her back through with him. So I guess they can live happily ever after? Though perhaps hungrily since they apparently ate their way through most of that world.

Sam and Dean make meaningful eye contact.

Sam: (rushing toward his brother) Dean?

Dean sees Sam and manages a smile.

Dean: Glad you could make it.

Which is Winchester for thank Chuck you’re okay.

Iconic Supernatural.

I love you Davy Perez for letting Dean Winchester utter the words “tentacle porn – not that there’s anything wrong with that” but I still want to know how much fanfic you’ve been reading. Also, don’t stop.

Ophelia hands over the Seal to them, warning them that the rift will only stay open for 24 hours.

The Winchesters return to the bunker, back to teasing each other but still a bit shaken up by the other being in peril.

Sam: You sure you’re all right?

Dean: For someone who was three seconds away from being an interdimensional booty call…

Like I said, fanfic.

What happens next ties together the two threads of the episode, the other one of which is Asmodeus, Ketch and Gabriel. Asmodeus (who makes my skin crawl, which I guess is how I’m supposed to feel but ewww) is out to mess with Ketch’s head, pulling a power play to put him in his place. He keeps calling Ketch to come and then making him wait, an insidious way of demonstrating his superiority – so well done it made my blood run cold.

Waiting room reading…

Meanwhile Asmodeus is forcibly (and painfully) extracting grace from poor Gabriel and shooting up with it, which explains why he’s so powerful. Richard Speight Jr. doesn’t have a single line in the episode, since Gabriel’s lips are sewn together, but he does an amazing job of conveying Gabriel’s terror and pain. He is so clearly traumatized, it’s in his eyes, in his constant flinches, in the little involuntary noises he makes. Richard does it so well it was painful to see, almost too realistic.

When Ketch gets past the demons who are distracted by cat videos and bursts in on Asmodeus, the power play accelerates into using force – as power plays so often do. Asmodeus beats Ketch up, which was terribly graphic and violent and disturbed me more than violence on this show usually does because it was couched in such a realistic scenario of abuse, and then taunts him, while Gabriel looks on.

Asmodeus: I own you. You get in line, boy.

This character is reprehensible, I’ll give you that, Show. Jeffrey Parise, you’re making me feel a little ill. Which I guess is a compliment.


He tells Ketch that he can see the fear and regret in his eyes, that he knows that Ketch secretly wants redemption – and that he’ll never have it

I’ve been expecting a redemption arc for Ketch, but I still don’t feel good about that. He did some truly unforgiveable things and I don’t think the Winchesters would forget about them. The whole Sam being tortured thing? I don’t think Dean could ever forgive that. I don’t think I can either. David Haydn-Jones does a good job here though, making Ketch a more sympathetic character than he has been in the past.

And once again, the VFX and the fight coordinating were just top notch here – everything in this episode was! The beautifully lit and eerie set dec, the music especially in the last scene, the special effects, the graphic violence and fighting even – it all came together to make a powerful episode.  Let’s not forget the makeup either, especially David Haydn-Jones post beat down, and Gabriel’s absolutely ruined face. Along with John Showalter’s directing and the amazing actors of course.

Asmodeus has pushed Ketch too far apparently; he decides to break out Gabriel, taking away Asmodeus’ drug of choice, and the two escape together – though Gabriel is clearly afraid to leave (also a disturbingly realistic abuse scenario).  I did think it was a little odd that Asmodeus left a beaten up Ketch in there with Gabriel, almost an invitation to take him…. hmmm. If this is an Asmodeus plot to infiltrate the bunker, I guess we’ll find out in due time. He is a shape shifter, after all.

That brings us to the Winchesters, back at the bunker.

Sam: Now all we need is an archangel…

Enter Mr. Ketch – and Gabriel. The Winchesters pull their guns in sync.

Ketch explains that he’s no longer working with Asmodeus, and in fact will be number one on his hit list now after stealing his “juice box” Gabriel.

Ketch: This is the only safe place I know.

And so he wants to stay there. (I mean, who can blame him??)

Sam says no, but Dean is quick to say yes – to anything that will get Mom and Jack back.  Once again, Dean calls the shots and Sam goes along, but clearly not so comfortably. That was a bit of a role reversal, since it usually seems like Sam is the one to say we need to put the past aside, we need to do this, and Dean to say no way.

Meanwhile, Richard Speight Jr. is once again doing an incredible job showing us Gabriel’s trauma. When the Winchesters needing his grace is mentioned, he flinches and starts whimpering and it just broke my heart. Even Ketch shows compassion, leaning down to reassure him that they’re not taking it, that he’s brought some with him.

One of my favorite little moments is Sam removing the stitches from Gabriel’s mouth. He’s so gentle doing it, shows so much compassion. Even to the archangel that was responsible for killing his brother hundreds of times in Mystery Spot.

Oh Sam, I do love you.

The last scene is masterful – like I said, exactly what Supernatural is all about. Dean wants to waste no time using the ingredients to open the rift, and that makes sense to me. Their mother could be on the verge of death – every minute counts.  But when Sam says he’ll go get his things, Dean once again says no, that he’s going alone.

Sam is clearly caught off guard by that pronouncement.

Ketch announces that he’s coming too, since he’d rather be not on this Earth so Asmodeus can find him.

Dean: Fine.

Sam: Fine? So you want Ketch to go and not me?

Sam is so much the little brother there, so obviously hurt by what Dean said.

Dean: I don’t care if HE dies, hell I’m kinda rooting for it…. If something happens to me, I need you to come and save me and Mom.

Sam looks so stricken – he just almost lost his brother to a tentacle monster, and now Dean is heading back to the AU, back to certain danger.


Dean (softer):  I know you don’t like this, I don’t expect you to. But this is the way it’s gonna be.

He says it with empathy, but also with finality.

You can see Sam struggle – Jared shows us this brilliantly – and finally nod almost imperceptibly. Dean can read his brother, half nods back. There’s sadness and regret in his eyes – it’s clear he doesn’t want to leave Sam behind but he also doesn’t want to risk him – and then he heaves his pack over his shoulder and Sam does the spell.

Sam: Twenty-four hours.

Dean wordlessly clasps Sam on the shoulder, the look exchanged between them saying all they need to say to each other more clearly than words ever could, and then he steps through the rift with Ketch.


Sam and Gabriel stay behind, and the look on Sam’s face tells me that he’s every bit as worried as I am.

I was surprised at Dean’s decision to go through the rift alone, and at his insistence. I guess it makes sense that they couldn’t leave a traumatized archangel behind in the bunker alone (or with Ketch), and I definitely get the sense of urgency – it has annoyed me multiple times this season that they’re not like WE HAVE TO GET TO MOM NOW! But it still was difficult, even if I am a fan of Dean’s protectiveness when it comes to his little brother.

And of course, we all know that nothing good ever comes from the Winchesters being separated – looks like Castiel is going to be the voice of reason where that’s concerned next episode.

I sort of shook my head at the end because this episode felt like it was way closer to the season finale – like they were already ramping up to the big showdown, but it’s only episode 17! That probably means we are in for something very very epic (in fact I got to watch some filming a week or so ago and I can say that we are definitely in for something very very epic…)  I am stocking up on tissues and wine and blankies and pie now!

Who’s with me??

Caps by @kayb625 with much gratitude.


Read the book written by the Supernatural

actors about their experience making the

show and how the fandom has changed

them in Family Don’t End With Blood,

links on our home page here!





10 thoughts on “‘The Thing’ – Iconic Supernatural!

  • Fantastic review! I really liked this episode. I do feel something epic coming on. Very nervous 🙂 One thought I had – do you think that is really Ketch? Shifter Asmodeus??? He was taking Gabriel’s grace for power to fight Lucifer? Just a thought! Loving this season!

  • LOVED the episode. Thanks for the review.
    I am disturbed by them not mentioning Cas. I think Dean rushed the jump so that he wouldn’t have to risk Cas as well.
    I think Dean is still traumatized by Cas’ death.

    Nice pickup on all the bro-moments. It feels like a sweet reminder of how good they are together before things turn pear shaped. Like ‘the last supper’ pizza meal with Charlie. Not good. I’m worried.

  • This is a classic episode. Hits all the Winchester marks. Direction, lighting, sets. writing,stunts. And Richard Speight Jr. as a broken Gabriel deserves an extra nod as he has not dialogue but conveys so much.. It does feel like we are ramping up to an awesome finale. It is never a good thing when the brothers are separated. This was an organic separation and came from a Davey Perez script. He so gets this show. Of course, Jared and Jensen are always at their best in this type of episode. Davey really pulls it all together here. Redemption is a common theme in this show, I just don’t know if Ketch has done enough. Waiting to see how he acts on the other side of the rift. Episode so good I almost forgot why the purple gemstone was so important. Notice a lot of grace infusions this season and the shape shifting is troublesome given that mistaken identity, nature v. nurture is reoccurring. Ratings were somewhat low- blacked out in certain cities due to sports- those folks missed a great one. Oh well, there is on demand but the ratings are network concerns even though season 14 is on order.

  • What an episode and thanks for breaking it down and posting such epic pictures. I thought exactly the same that it was leading up to the finale but I honestly think what else can go wrong for the brothers. I was delighted to see our favorite arc angel back. Will it be Cas that brings him back to full strength who knows. Can’t wait for ep18.

  • This episode contained so many iconic moments it was almost overwhelming! When Jensen mentioned “tentacle porn” on The Talk I thought we were in for another meta-episode. So many fanfic tropes! Not that I’ve read much tentacle porn *ahem*

  • Tentacle Porn. Fan fiction Sam,Dean,Gabriel, and Ketch. Who could ask for anything more? I’ve read it too. Don’t ask why and don’t judge. Just sayin…

  • I had to wait to watch thsi one as it was preempted by baseball in my area! But, watched the next night on the CW app, thank Chuck! Thanks for your review, I love reading your posts and seeing your pics. I agree the seperation anxiety has set in. Not sure I trust anyone and also thought it weird that Asmodeus left Ketch and Gabriel together alone. Also thought it interesting that Asmodeus even needed Gabriel’s grace? Not sure I understand that. He is/was a Prince of Hell, doesnt that already make him more powerful? Anyway….not looking forward to hellatus, think its going to be a tough one.

  • I really have to go back and read all the reviews of your eps, I so thoroughly enjoy your take on the show; you love so much of what I love!

    “hmmm. If this is an Asmodeus plot to infiltrate the bunker, I guess we’ll find out in due time. He is a shape shifter, after all.”

    –Oh fascinating, I did not think of that!

    I was bothered by the ending scene at first, that Dean made the decision to go alone himself rather than mutually talking it out with Sam. But thinking about it more — this isn’t just Dean’s baseline big-brother over-protectiveness. Sam has been off for several episodes now (he keeps getting captured/knocked out by normal humans…) Something’s up with him — maybe he’s not over the depression crushing him before, maybe he’s just not sleeping enough (too much research, or Lucifer nightmares?) or something else; but he’s not at peak performance. And the Apocaverse is too dangerous for anyone not at the top of their game; they both know it.

    But Dean isn’t going to say that outright if he doesn’t have to. And Sam has always had a really hard time coming to terms with not being strong enough to do anything (even when it’s not his fault, when he’s been through so much trauma and grief that it’s amazing he can even get out of bed). But if Dean makes the call — then Sam doesn’t have to feel like a failure. Doesn’t have to admit that before he goes plunging into an alternate universe to save his family, he could use twenty-four hours to breathe (…while watching over an archangel whom a Prince of Hell is gunning for…but hey, by Supernatural standards that’s a spa day!)

  • I definitely needed this type of episode last week. All of the humor, the brother dynamics, and the return to the season’s story arc made it a great episode, but having Gabriel back really lifted my spirits during a difficult week. Even if he is broken right now, seeing him on screen brings back memories of the Trickster who I’ve loved even when he was torturing our favorite brothers.

    Thanks for a great recap of the episode!

Leave a Reply