Romcoms are not usually my thing – but for Jared Padalecki I will make an exception. Actually, ‘Guarding Stars’ was entitled to two exceptions. First, thanks to my enduring love of ‘Supernatural’, I’ll at least give a try to pretty much anything Jared Padalecki or Jensen Ackles are in. Two, things that are seem like they might be sappy or sentimental are not usually my thing either – except at Christmas. Then you can get as sappy and sentimental as you want, and I’ll sit there grinning with my eyes watering.
‘Guarding Stars’ hit all those notes, and yes, I may have teared up once or twice. And enjoyed every minute of it!
Like all good romcoms (and lots of good fanfic), there were multiple tropes gleefully peppered throughout the story. The more unlikely they were, the more they made me smile as Jack and Hannah got tossed into one unlikely situation after another. There was the end-up-on-the-ground on top of each other trope.
Twice. Maybe three times.
There was the seeing through the exterior gruffness to the vulnerability underneath – and refreshingly that applied to both main characters! There was the time honored fake girlfriend/fake boyfriend trope with a kiss cam moment to bring their lips (reluctantly?) together.
There was only one bed.
And not only that, there was only one horse too!
Jared and Leighton Meester sold all of those tropes effortlessly. Even when I was giggling at an over the top scenario (the crazy stalker chick and Hannah riding to the rescue on a horse even though she didn’t know how to ride), I was thoroughly enjoying myself.
There were Christmas carols and tree decorating with adorable mischievous children to put you in the holiday mood (and to help Hannah remember what it feels like to have a family and let someone else in emotionally).
There was Jared playing guitar, which I’ve witnessed once or twice in real life but I always wish we’d see a lot more often. And Jared looking movie star glamorous, sunglasses reflecting the snow, all long legs and scruff and cowboy hat and an air of I-know-I’m-hot that Padalecki does not convey in real life even though he is. (Sorry if I’m embarrassing you, Jared…)
We even got a glimpse of Jared-as-Jack advertising beautiful watches, which Padalecki is quite a fan of in real life. And snagging the cover of People Magazine’s Sexiest Man Alive.
The film also had enough realistic sadness and loss to keep it from being saccharine. Both Hannah and Jack have had their share of family tragedy, and at the start neither have dealt with it. With a little help from Jack’s mother, determined to help her family heal as she fights a possibly terminal diagnosis herself, Jack eventually realizes he can’t run away from his past trauma – and we see how much his unearned guilt has cost him. Hannah sees it too, and eventually takes down some of her own walls to risk an emotional attachment after losing her mother, first to difficult family circumstances as a child and then to death. The sibling resentment between Jack and his younger brother and the way it impacted the rest of the family was surprisingly real too. (Andie McDowell was wonderful as Jack’s mother, and reminded me so much of Molly Hagan as Cordell’s mother on Walker).
We got to see Jared being the big brother for a change – Noah LaLonde was believable as the younger brother left behind to try to hold the family together after their tragic loss, but who resents that his older brother left them all behind, seemingly for fame and fortune.
Special shout out to the last minute twist at the end, which I did not see coming. I knew there would be a romcom happy ending, but I didn’t anticipate it happening that way! (Thank you, Katherine Center, for writing Hannah as not entirely a damsel in distress at the end – she needed to get out of that chair and kick ass and she did!) I haven’t read the book, and it was adapted for the screen, but the core story and the characters in the film are really well written, so shout out to Katherine too.
Oh, and the little glimpse of Gen Padalecki (a producer on the film and the one who realized it would a) make a great movie and b) that her husband totally had to play Jack), back on horseback where she looks so comfortable, was a nice little surprise! ‘Guarding Stars’ was a family affair – Jared and Gen’s middle child Shep played a young Jack in old home movies and did a great job.
Much of the credit for how entertaining the film was goes to Padalecki and Meester, who are both versatile enough as actors to sell the humor, the emotional journey, and the budding romance. It’s been a while since we got to see Jared tap into the sensitive side of a character, which he can do so well. I was reminded a few times of Sam Winchester, who felt similarly guilty and convinced that anyone he got involved with would be harmed, and who was a sensitive soul even when he was a total badass fighting demons. Padalecki can convey a lot of emotion with just an expression or tone of voice, and painted layers to Jack almost from the start. He made it entirely believable that Hannah would fall for him, as unlikely as that seemed at the start. I’d forgotten how good he is at witty banter too!
I didn’t watch any of Leighton’s previous shows, so she was a pleasant surprise as an actor also. Genuinely funny with great timing – sometimes just her facial expression made me laugh. She too can convey a lot with just the look in her eyes, hinting at a lot of hurt and loneliness at way too young an age. Her response to Jack’s gift, hearing the song her mother sang to her – one of the seemingly few really good memories of her – was heartbreaking. One of my tear up moments.
It’s Christmas, so the happy ending was fine with me. Who am I kidding, I love happy endings any time of year.
If you haven’t watched ‘Guarding Stars’ yet, it’s streaming on Netflix. Enjoy!
-Lynn
You can read Jared Padalecki’s heartfelt
and very personal chapter in the book
Family Don’t End With Blood, info and
links on the home page or at:
